Theeconomyortheenvironmentmustwechoose?第1页

OnApril20,

GulfofMexicoOilSpilled.第2页

OnMarch11,

Fukushimanuclearplantexploded.第3页

OnJune4,

BohaiSeaoilspilled.第4页

OnAugust27,massfishdiedinGutian,FujianProvince.第5页

OnSeptember12,aFrancenuclearplantexploded.第6页

April20,MexicoMarch11,JapanJune4,ChinaAugust27,ChinaSeptember12,Francewhenwhere......?第7页

Humanbeingeconomyenvironment第8页

mustwechoose?economyenvironment第9页

Debateadebate---acontesttwoormorespeakerstrytopersuadeoneanotherpropositionoppositionchairpersonargument(论点)supportingdetails第10页

Today’shostJamesLong第11页

Debaters:MsLinShuiqing：aspokeswomanfromtheGreenSocietyMrQianLiwei:abusinessdevelopmentconsultant第12页

LinShuiqingPart1MsLin’sspeech第13页

FastreadingByhowmanytimeshastheworldspopulationincreasedsince1800?MsLin’sspeech第14页

1.Whatistheresultofchemicalwaste?2.Whatishappeningtolargenumbersoffish?3.WhatsuggestionsdoesMsLingiveusattheendofherspeech?Detailedreading第15页

ConclusionMsLin’sargument:Humanbeingsshouldn’tdeveloptheeconomyattheexpenseof(以…为代价)theenvironment.environmentalist第16页

QianLiweiWhatisyourfirstimpressionofbusinessmen？Part2MrQian’sspeech第17页

MrQian’sargument:Ahealthyenvironmentanddevelopmentshouldbepossibleatthesametime.第18页

MrQian’ssupportingdetails:control/repairbedeeplyconcernedaboutpeoplemoreimportantrecycledmaterials/rawbetterlawshigherprice/taxes×第19页

Similarity:Differences:Newideas:recyclingfactoriesproductionbetterlawshigherprice/taxescomparison第20页

Post-readingRetell(复述)twodebatersspeechesandexpressyourownideasaswell.第21页

Ms.LinShuiqing:Humanbeingsshouldnotdeveloptheeconomyattheexpenseof(以…为代价)